Skip to main content

A Great Time Saver

As the case for nurse practitioners is becoming increasingly obvious across the spectrum, predictably, the turf battles are rearing their ugly heads. Here is a blatant example of the rhetoric and follows a formula that I am going to reveal to spare any future time wasting reading them.


  • Refer to the physician shortage and mention "Obamacare" 
  • State the obligatory, "nurse practitioners are valued as part of the health care team" 
  • Point out the differences in education and training (for example, physicians have 1 billion hours of training where NPs have nothing even remotely close to that) 
  • Make the inference that quality of care will somehow suffer because of the differences in education/training (though there is not one shred of evidence that proves this)
  • Make sure NOT to mention anything about patient outcomes being the same or better when NPs are primary care providers
  • If there is mention of outcome studies, be sure to highlight how they are "old" studies with small numbers of patients
  • Conclude by saying something with the phrase "physician-led team"
There you have it! I hope with this post, I was able to save the reader time wasted reading the same old argument. 

As a bonus, for on-line stories that allow readers to comment, I am going to save you time from reading the barrage of denigrating comments by summarizing here:
  • Blah blah blah...as a medical student blah blah blah....physicians should stop teaching NPs/PAs etc
  • Blah blah blah...(make statement about NP education yet have no clue about it)...blah blah
  • And finally, state that NPs won't see the poor and underserved and prefer to practice in the "better" practices with insured patients 
Of course, this is not the sentiment of most and the one's who truly want to improve health care understand that. 

Comments

Unknown said…
Excellent synopsis. Just need to add "signed Joe or Jane Smith MD member of (pick a state) medical society"
You must have been reading the same blogs as me ;P

Seriously...why are they so threatened by us?

My physician partners couldn't be more supportive of me. So yes, it CAN work...
Unknown said…
You forgot the usual, "if they wanted to practice medicine, they should have gone to medical school to be a doctor."

Popular posts from this blog

Private Practice

There is an interesting trend that I'm observing and don't necessarily see how this is going to turn out. I'm seeing more and more nurse practitioner's opening their own autonomous practices. Many of these offices set out to offer care that is personalized, covered under insurance, and of course high-quality. I'm also seeing more NP specialty/sub-specialty practices such as house calls, incontinence, and women's health. This is in a time when more physician practices are joining together in these conglomerations that aren't necessarily tied to hospitals. You'd be hard pressed to find a solo primary care physician these days yet nurse practitioner solo practices are popping up. The talk about the formation of accountable care organizations can be attributed to health care reform and the spurring of large multi-physician practices. What to make of this? I honestly don't know. Many people and patients have said to me "you should start your own prac...

NP Residency

The healthcare system of today is so complex yet so dysfunctional that I believe the time has come to educate and train the NP providers of tomorrow in a way that is reflective of that complexity. We have done a good job up to this point but need to bring that to the next level. Residency. I'm not necessarily referring to the typical residency training of physicians which takes place in hospitals but a residency-type of program in an out-patient setting (ironic that we use the term residency). We realize that healthcare is not exclusively delivered in hospitals. It takes place in independent providers offices, in community health centers, in mobile health vans, and in retail settings. It takes place in people's homes and places of employment. It takes place in many of the health decisions that we make on a daily basis. I found this NP residency program in Connecticut that claims to be the first NP residency in the US. The programs admits 4 NPs each year and trains them to ha...

Precepting Students

I've precepted many NP students during the years and usually had pretty rewarding experiences. (There was that one student that just didn't get it...I guess I can save that one and how I handled it for another post!) I like to think of precepting as a two-way street: my student is getting the hands on experience of patient care with guidance while I can further hone my precepting skills. Precepting a student is not simply telling them how to treat a condition or how to prescribe a medication. It is helping that student critically think to formulate differential diagnoses and treatment plans. Precepting can often be overlooked as part of the education and training of health professionals yet it is a critical part of acquiring the necessary skill set of patient care. I think back to my experiences as a student and have found supportive clinicians that helped to shape me into the clinician I am today (I was precepted by a Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine, an OB/GYN, a family nur...